Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia have been identified as the world's three largest historical exporters of carbon dioxide, according to an analysis of fossil fuel exports since 1850 that attributes emissions to the countries extracting the fuels rather than those burning them.
Russia tops the ranking, with responsibility for more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2 emissions generated by burning its exported coal, oil and gas through the end of 2025.
Saudi Arabia ranks second, with approximately 60 gigatonnes of exported CO2, followed by Australia with more than 25 gigatonnes, placing it slightly ahead of Venezuela.
The findings come as Australia presides over this year's UN climate summit, Cop31, which has entered its second week in Turkey.
Despite its role in the negotiations, Australia has yet to establish an end date for fossil fuel use or exports, which account for about two-fifths of its export economy.
Louise Hutchins, the convener of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, said: “This analysis tells you a lot about what’s going wrong with climate negotiations. Here at Cop31, governments claim there’s not enough money to tackle the climate crisis, while Australia, Russia and Saudi Arabia, that have amassed fortunes from fossil fuels, continue to wield pivotal political power in this consensus-based process.
“Just look at Australia. Its contribution to global heating more than doubles when fossil fuel exports are counted. Yet it is co-presiding over the very negotiations where climate finance talks are once again in stalemate.
“Responsibility is on the wealthy, the powerful and the profiteers. Those who made fortunes from fossil fuels must pay for the damage.”
The analysis, conducted by Carbon Brief and seen by the Guardian, calculates historical CO2 emissions according to the countries where fossil fuels were extracted, rather than where they were consumed.
This approach presents a different picture of historical responsibility for global emissions, as countries that export large quantities of fossil fuels can rank relatively low in conventional emissions assessments that focus on domestic consumption.
However, the analysis also shows that the United States and China, the world's two largest current greenhouse gas emitters, remain more responsible for historical emissions than Russia, Saudi Arabia or Australia because they have both imported and burned substantial quantities of fossil fuels while also using their own resources.
Meanwhile, the findings come amid continuing disagreements over the global transition away from fossil fuels.
The outcome of the Cop28 UN climate conference in Dubai in 2023 called on all countries to contribute to a global transition away from fossil fuels but established no timetable or work plan.
At Cop31, Australia issued the first draft of a potential summit outcome on Monday afternoon, calling for “the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems”.
However, several countries, including Saudi Arabia, have hardened their negotiating positions since the Dubai conference, while the absence of the United States under Donald Trump has reduced pressure on them to reach compromises.
The proposed language is widely expected to face resistance during further revisions of the summit's final decision text.
Saudi Arabia, Russia and their allies in the Arab group and other negotiating blocs are also opposing the idea of issuing a cover text, potentially further complicating the negotiations.
Separately, Climate Analytics published an analysis on Tuesday indicating that Australia has no apparent plans to reduce its domestic fossil fuel extraction despite presiding over Cop31.
The thinktank said coal mines were still being approved that could remain operational until 2088, decades beyond the period when countries are expected to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions around mid-century.
Bill Hare, CEO of Climate Analytics, said: “It’s abundantly clear Australia is not ‘doing its part’ as the prime minister claimed here in Turkey last week. There is a deep contradiction in a government position that champions climate ambition abroad but plans for continued fossil fuel exports, with approvals for coalmines and gasfields that lock in production for decades.”
The issue also presents domestic political challenges for the Australian government.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese attended Cop31 last week but faces growing pressure at home from the resurgent One Nation party, which is polling strongly, rejects net zero targets and denies climate science.
Australia, Saudi Arabia and Russia were approached for comment.
Asad Rehman, the chief executive of Friends of the Earth, said: “It’s time for the deadly tango between the producers of fossil fuels, and those locked into dependency on oil and gas, to have its last dance. We must turn off the tap on fossil fuels and push richer nations to commit to a fair, fast and fully funded phaseout. That means real public finance, and access to the technology that can make it possible, for the countries bearing the brunt of climate breakdown.”